In the extensively vast realm of literature, there exists a realm of fame and glory known as the ‘#1 New York Times bestseller’ club. You have seen these words on countless book covers, hold a magnetic allure for authors and readers. Yet, a lingering question haunts the discerning minds: Can every book that claims this prestigious title truly be deserving? I have grabbed a few in the early years of my reading journey, and realized how I have been fooled by the cover, it is simple as they say – Don’t Judge A Book By Its Cover.

The New York Times Best Seller list stands as a testament to the popularity and commercial success of books. But what exactly tags a book to this esteemed list? What are the criteria they have set to make a book best seller!

The most important part starts at the New York Times office, where a hardworking team works diligently to create the famous bestseller list. They start by carefully looking at the number of books sold each week all over the country. But selling a lot of books alone doesn’t guarantee a place on the list; there are complex evaluations that go deeper into the impact of the books.

The New York Times team employs a multidimensional approach, considering various factors beyond sales numbers. While the exact algorithm remains shrouded in secrecy, whispers within the publishing industry suggest that the team also takes into account critical acclaim, cultural impact, and even the author’s reputation. It is a delicate balancing act, an artful dance where commercial success converges with artistic merit.
But what about the categories that define the New York Times Best Seller list? These distinct genres and classifications hold immense power in determining a book’s fate. From fiction to nonfiction, hardcover to paperback, young adult to advice, a book can find its place in a multitude of niches. This intricate categorization allows for a diverse range of books to claim the bestseller status. Even if a book resides at the bottom rungs of a category, it can proudly brandish the ‘New York Times bestseller’ tag for eternity.

They say an author has to sell minimum of 5000 books to get into the list of *#NYT best sellers to get notified by the world. Even if their books are not read by many, they can still become best selling authors. Since the best-seller list comes out every week, a lot of books get the chance to appear on it.

Yet, the path to literary stardom is not without its controversies. Whispers echo through the corridors of the publishing world, suggesting that some publishing companies strategically maneuver their books onto the bestseller list. Allegations abound that slots on the list are purchased in advance, enabling publishers to orchestrate a grand symphony of marketing campaigns to boost sales and secure a spot among the literary elite. While these claims remain largely unverified, they serve as a stark reminder that the quest for bestseller status is not always an organic ascent.

The New York Times bestseller list is not immune to criticism either. Some voices decry alleged biases within the ranks, pointing fingers at a perceived favoritism towards certain authors or political leanings. These allegations raise questions about the objectivity of the selection process and its impact on the literary landscape. However, it is crucial to remember that the New York Times bestseller list is just one among numerous bestseller lists that exist. The literary world is a tapestry of accolades, and a book need only claim a spot on one of these lists to achieve bestseller status.

I have read a handful of books, the NYT bestsellers as they say and ended up regretting the time and choice I made. I have even noticed books coveted with Bestseller print even in the first edition of its publishing, and upon investigating a little deeper, I came across the fact that a few teeny tiny companies can give you the title if you are ready to increase your budget!


The world is witnessing a drastic decrease in the number of authentic book readers, but simultaneously they say that there is an increase in online readers. Unfortunately I still do not believe that sitting in a corner with a digital book in hand can give you the exact emotion of an old class reader of an authentic book. They are incomparable to me. Books are even tagged as bestsellers in the first publication, because they have done better in the online world.

When you go a bit further to the New York Times Best Seller list, it becomes clear that the path to literary success is multifaceted and often shrouded in mystery. Sales figures, critical acclaim, and the intricate dance of marketing strategies all play a role in determining a book’s destiny. While controversies and allegations persist, the allure of the ‘#1 New York Times bestseller’ title continues to captivate authors and readers alike.

If you are a serious reader, you cannot hold yourself from grabbing that shiny Bestseller piled like a mountain in the entrance of a bookstore. But to save you from regretting later, it is always better to read a few pages, at least a chapter before buying it and it would definitely give you the idea about the style of the book, whether it favors your reading style or not. If that is impossible, just walk away, Go home, Get a complete review of the book and that satisfies you, yes Go On and Grab it. It is evident that, behind every title lies a tale of literary ambition, marketing prowess, and the delicate interplay between art and commerce. The world of bestsellers is a realm where dreams are realized, and where the words on a page can transcend their humble origins to captivate the hearts and minds of readers across the globe.

Pic Courtesy : Google
Images used are for descriptive purpose only